The European Commission's decision to ban the use of the terms ‘probiotic’ and prebiotic’ is downright crazy given the available scientific evidence. The instrument used to achieve this incredible infringement on commercial freedom of speech is the EU Nutrition and Health Claims Regulation (NHCR). Despite its lofty ideals of supporting the EU’s obesity strategy and abolishing consumer confusion over food/dietary supplements, NHCR has done little more than create an information blackout, kneecapping companies from effective, and in many cases, truthful marketing of their products. Seen as a pharma protectionist measure by many, NHCR has failed to slow down sales of probiotic products that are still flying off the shelves despite there being not a single authorised EU health claim. Clearly consumer interest and knowledge of the health benefits of these products is undimmed whether you have to refer to them as bacteria, microorganisms or microbiotics in the EU and probiotics if you live outside!
Those of us in the natural health field have long been aware of the importance of the vast community of microbes that dwell in and on us. Now, Big Food and Pharma is trying to jump on the bandwagon. Yet, in true big corp fashion, a new study highlights the 600 new patents that have been registered since 2008 for products aimed at improving gut microbiome health. Few patents have been abandoned which alludes to the high value placed on products of this nature for their commercial return. Big corporates behind patent registrations to date include 4D Pharma PLC, Seres Therapeutics, Intellectual Ventures Management, Nestle SA and Crestovo llc.
Probiotics aren’t new
The World Health Organization defines probiotics as “live microorganisms which when administered in adequate amounts confer a health benefit on the host”. Whilst some microbes create disease, probiotic microbes work by modulating the environment they inhabit to crowd out unwanted organisms and allow the so called ‘good’ bacteria and other beneficial microorganisms to grow and thrive.
Human use of live microorganisms stretches as far back as Neolithic man. Far from a new phenomenon, the use of faecal microbiota transplants to combat diarrhoea and severe food poisoning can be traced back to fourth-century China, whilst Hippocrates famously declared ‘death sits in the bowels’. Our ancestors recognised the benefits of fermenting to both preserve food and enhance its health benefits (even if they didn’t fully understand why!). The range of traditional fermented foods, and the ingredients used, is vast and varied according to country.
Once considered the domain of hippies and health advocates, probiotic foods such as yogurt and latterly dietary supplements, have now gone mainstream, gaining acceptance among the general public. In the rush to leverage a lucrative consumer demand, the market for products containing pre- and probiotics is growing on an almost daily basis.
Corporate stranglehold on probiotics?
Failing antibiotics and shrinking blockbuster product pipelines are forcing pharmaceutical companies to look for alternatives. It was only a matter of time before they turned their sights to probiotics. Investment is high as the race to dominate the market increases, a market that that until now, has been largely confined to natural health companies. This brings more pressure to bear on regulatory authorities to institute more stringent regulations, potentially crowding out smaller companies without the funds to jump through complex legal hoops.
Think of food and you are likely to be able to buy a probiotic version! Everything from water (yes really!) to chocolate, pet food, superfood salads, snack bars and nut butter are but a few of the growing range of probiotic-containing functional foods hitting the supermarket shelves. All promising improvements to our health. Well, all, if you live outside of the EU. Those of us in the EU will get a range of microorganism-filled products that doesn’t sound quite as appealing unless you know that’s code for probiotics.
As with so many natural products and ingredients hijacked by Big Food or Big Pharma, the resulting product is often much less desirable after the corporate 'suits' cut the cost of the ingredients for a better profit margin. That’s why you see products with lower quality ingredients, artificial sweeteners, preservatives and cheap fillers wrapped up with smart marketing designed to lure us into believing they are the health panacea we’re looking for.
Research in recent years has shown that probiotics confer a wide and varied range of health benefits including reversing obesity, improving gut health, mental health, skin health and so much more. The clue to their essentiality may be in the fact that we are only 1% human DNA, the rest is microbial.
Attention is increasingly turning to the use of probiotics in agriculture to improve soil and plant health, increase productivity and bring balance back to surrounding ecosystems without the need for harmful chemical pesticides and herbicides. With the increasing issue of antibiotic resistance looming large, reducing reliance on antibiotics in animal production is also high on the agenda.
As Big Pharma seeks further ways to exploit the health benefits of microorganisms, they’re turning their attention to harnessing ‘postbiotics’. The metabolic by-products created by microorganisms as they convert the food we eat into health promoting substances such as short-chain fatty acids and amino acids. Something that we can do perfectly naturally in our own guts provided we eat plenty of fibre-laden vegetables and fruit.
Take your gut health seriously
Probiotic (microbiotic, microorganism) supplements can be very helpful at certain times in your life. However, it is always best to take a food-first approach and prioritise whole, unprocessed foods to cultivate a truly healthy gut naturally. Creating robust and diverse colonies of the right kinds of microbes will give you the resilience you need to withstand the rigours of life long into your senior years.
Familiarise yourself with the ANH Food4Health guidelines designed to create health by promoting a healthy gut microbiome
Drastically reduce processed and ultra-processed foods in your diet as these contain a lot of preservatives which damage your enzymes and microbiota, as well as sugar, which promotes the growth of unhealthy microbial colonies
Feed your gut bugs! Aim to eat at least 2 different kinds of vegetables at every meal, 3 if you can. Add in 2-3 portions of fruit. The fibre is undigested by us, but provides essential food for our microbes
Discover and cultivate a taste for traditionally fermented foods such as sauerkraut, kimchi, kefir, tempeh and natto. Experiment with fermenting at home, it’s really quite easy. If you do buy your ferments though, check they are raw, unpasteurised and don’t contain vinegar - and remember that olives are a fermented food too, as is yoghurt (but preferably not of the sweetened variety!)
Eat a rainbow every day. Include vegetables and fruit covering the spectrum of 6 colours to extract their full health benefits
Eat a diverse range of foods and keep experimenting with new foods
Where possible try to prioritise organic foods to reduce your (and your gut bugs) exposure to pesticides and herbicides
Move regularly every day. You don’t have to go to the gym, but being active every day in a variety of ways (particularly if you can get outdoors) benefits your gut microbiome by improving diversity, supporting digestion, burning fat and ameliorating the effects of being overweight or obese
Lastly, but very importantly, eat small to moderate portion sizes to avoid over-eating at meal times. Chew your food properly, eat slowly and take time to ‘rest and digest’. Leaving gaps of at least 5 hours between meals allows your gut bugs to recover and flourish before the next food onslaught occurs.
In his blog, ANH's founder likens the global condition we face to an autoimmune condition and suggests it's time to apply the lessons we've learnt from autoimmunity to the way we react to other humans.